It's like, “You just let me put my penis in your ass and move it in and out I'm going to try to put the feeling of anal sex into words so you can get. Some say it feels intense and great, while others say anal sex is horrible. are willing to give it a try the first question they often have is, what does it feel like?. For women who are interested in anal sex, I got a lot out of the book: Anal Pleasure and Health: But I like having it as the little secret that I truly enjoy, and I don't think I'm an anomaly. Consider this More women are having anal sex. 12 Men Share What It's Really Like To Be Giving Or Receiving Since we know how women feel about anal sex, I spoke with 6 gay men and 6. Depends. Giving or receiving? Giving, I've always thought was kind of meh. I mean, I've had partners who like receiving it, so I've done it on occasion, but. Many women don't want to have anal sex because they fear it will be painful, but here's what anal sex really feels like for a woman.